Is Patrick Mahomes A-List?
No — Patrick Mahomes is currently ranked B tier — a well-known figure with a strong career but not quite a household name.
Reached A-list in 2020
Wins Super Bowl LIV MVP
Lost A-list status in 2024
Dropped to B tier — Historic Three-Peat Super Bowl Championship
Ranking Timeline
Drafted 10th Overall by Chiefs
Mahomes was selected by Kansas City after trading up, signing a four-year $16.4M rookie deal. He sat his first season behind Alex Smith as the unproven backup.
MVP in First Season as Starter
Mahomes threw 50 TDs and 5,000 yards in his first year starting, winning NFL MVP. The historic season announced him as the league's next great quarterback.
Wins Super Bowl LIV MVP
At 24, Mahomes led the Chiefs to their first Super Bowl in 50 years, earning MVP. His clutch fourth-quarter comeback cemented his status as an elite quarterback and face of the NFL.
Signs Record $503M Extension
Mahomes signed the largest contract in sports history, a 10-year $503M deal. The groundbreaking contract plus massive endorsements made him the NFL's premier star and marketing force.
Second Super Bowl Victory
Mahomes won his second Super Bowl MVP, leading a comeback victory over the Eagles. The win solidified his dynasty trajectory and GOAT conversation inclusion at age 27.
Historic Three-Peat Super Bowl Championship
Mahomes led the Chiefs to an unprecedented third straight Super Bowl, joining elite company. Despite historic success, younger stars like Lamar Jackson and rising rookies have diversified NFL attention, settling him at B-tier cultural relevance despite on-field dominance.
Last updated: February 23, 2026