Is Nicolás Otamendi A-List?
No — Nicolás Otamendi is currently ranked B tier — a well-known figure with a strong career but not quite a household name.
Reached A-list in 2015
Manchester City Signing
Lost A-list status in 2020
Dropped to B tier — Benfica Return
Ranking Timeline
Porto Move and Success
Otamendi moves to Porto, establishing himself as a key defender and winning titles. This increases his visibility and market value.
Valencia Transfer
Otamendi transfers to Valencia, further showcasing his defensive skills. This sets the stage for a bigger move.
Manchester City Signing
Otamendi signs with Manchester City, marking a significant step in his career. His salary and endorsements increase substantially.
Premier League Champion
Otamendi wins the Premier League with Manchester City. This solidifies his status as a top defender.
Benfica Return
Otamendi moves to Benfica, taking a leadership role. This represents a slight step back from his peak.
World Cup Champion
Otamendi wins the World Cup with Argentina, which is great for his legacy.
Benfica Captain, Key Player
Otamendi continues to captain Benfica, remaining a key player. He is respected for his experience and leadership.
Last updated: February 25, 2026