
Is James McCarthy A-List?
No — James McCarthy is currently ranked C tier — recognizable within their niche but with limited mainstream visibility.
Ranking Timeline
Hamilton Academical Debut
Begins his professional career at Hamilton Academical. Early career earnings are modest.
Joins Wigan Athletic
Moves to Wigan Athletic, a significant step up in his career and salary.
FA Cup Winner
Wins the FA Cup with Wigan, increasing his profile and value.
Everton Transfer
Joins Everton, establishing himself as a key player in midfield and earning a higher salary.
Crystal Palace Move
Moves to Crystal Palace, continuing his Premier League career.
Celtic Return
Returns to Scotland to play for Celtic, a move closer to home.
Wigan Athletic Return
Returns to Wigan Athletic again. Career is now slowing down.
Coaching Future
Transitioning to coaching or media roles after his playing career, maintaining a stable financial position.
Last updated: February 21, 2026