Is James Marsters A-List?
No — James Marsters is currently ranked B tier — a well-known figure with a strong career but not quite a household name.
Ranking Timeline
Joins 'Buffy' as Spike
Marsters joins the cast of 'Buffy the Vampire Slayer' as the vampire Spike, a recurring role that becomes a fan favorite.
Spike Becomes Series Regular
Spike becomes a series regular on 'Buffy', increasing Marsters's visibility and demand.
Angel and Buffy Wrap Up
After Buffy and Angel wrap up, Marsters stays visible with a string of cameos and musical releases.
Smallville Recurring Role
He appeared in Smallville playing a villainous character, building his portfolio.
'Torchwood' Appearance
Marsters appears in 'Torchwood', further solidifying his sci-fi/fantasy credentials and fanbase.
Runaways Recurring Role
Appears in a recurring role in Marvel's Runaways, increasing his appeal to a new generation.
Steady Career, Cult Following
Continues acting, writing, and performing music, maintaining a steady career and devoted fanbase.
Last updated: February 25, 2026