Is Hilarie Burton A-List?
No — Hilarie Burton is currently ranked B tier — a well-known figure with a strong career but not quite a household name.
Ranking Timeline
Starts on TRL
Starts as a VJ on MTV's Total Request Live, gaining early exposure.
'One Tree Hill' Debut
Cast as Peyton Sawyer, her breakthrough role.
'One Tree Hill' Exit
Leaves 'One Tree Hill', seeking new opportunities.
Recurring 'White Collar' Role
Recurring role on 'White Collar', maintaining visibility.
Guest Role on 'Grey's'
Appears on 'Grey's Anatomy', expanding acting credits.
'Lethal Weapon' Role
Takes on a recurring role in 'Lethal Weapon'.
Active in TV
Hilarie continues to work in television, known for her roles in 'One Tree Hill' and other series, as well as her presence as co-host of the Drama Queens podcast.
Last updated: February 21, 2026