Is Dorothy McGuire A-List?
No — Dorothy McGuire is currently ranked B tier — a well-known figure with a strong career but not quite a household name.
Ranking Timeline
Film Debut in *Claudia*
McGuire makes her film debut, quickly establishing herself.
*Gentleman's Agreement* Nomination
Her role earns her an Academy Award nomination, solidifying her status.
*Trial* Acclaim
She stars in *Trial*.
*Friendly Persuasion* Recognition
McGuire wins the National Board of Review Award for Best Actress.
*Old Yeller* Mother Role
Her role in the classic family film endears her to a broader audience.
*Swiss Family Robinson* Success
Another family-friendly film adds to her popularity and financial success.
Later Career TV Roles
McGuire continues to work in television, maintaining a steady career.
Retirement Years
McGuire is mostly retired, living off her successful career earnings.
Remembered Classic Actress
McGuire's legacy endures through her classic film roles, cementing her as a respected actress of her era.
Last updated: February 21, 2026