Is Ben Simmons A-List?

NBA Draft First Pick

Selected first overall by Philadelphia 76ers after one season at LSU. Injured entire rookie year but hype remained high for generational point-forward talent.

Wins Rookie of Year

Despite sitting out previous season, won award over Donovan Mitchell in controversial vote. Versatile playmaking and defense made him face of Sixers' rebuild alongside Joel Embiid.

Signs $170M Max Extension

Five-year designated rookie max contract made him one of NBA's highest-paid players. Three-time All-Star and elite defender at age 23 seemed destined for superstardom.

Playoff Collapse and Refusal

Passed up wide-open dunk in Game 7 loss, then refused to shoot in fourth quarters. Public criticism from teammates and coach Doc Rivers began dramatic decline in reputation.

Holds Out Entire Season

Demanded trade and refused to play for Sixers, citing mental health issues. Year-long saga resulted in fines and made him one of NBA's most criticized and polarizing figures.

Traded to Brooklyn Nets

Sent to Nets in blockbuster James Harden deal but never played due to back injury. High-profile trade quickly looked disastrous as health issues kept him sidelined entire season.

Returns but Plays 42 Games

Finally played but looked tentative and injury-prone, missing most of season again. Once-elite skills appeared diminished while earning max salary without All-Star production.

Ongoing Injury and Criticism

Continued missing significant time with various injuries, playing fewer than 60 games since 2021. Widely considered one of NBA's worst contracts with skills and reputation in tatters, mostly forgotten by casual fans.