Is Andy Carroll A-List?
No — Andy Carroll is currently ranked C tier — recognizable within their niche but with limited mainstream visibility.
Reached A-list in 2011
Liverpool Transfer
Lost A-list status in 2013
Dropped to B tier — West Ham Move
Ranking Timeline
Newcastle Breakthrough
Carroll establishes himself at Newcastle United, showing promise as a striker. His value starts to increase as he gains recognition.
Liverpool Transfer
Carroll makes a high-profile move to Liverpool for a significant fee. His salary and profile skyrocket, substantially increasing his net worth.
West Ham Move
Carroll joins West Ham United, continuing to earn a high salary. Despite injury issues, his net worth remains strong.
Returns to Newcastle
Carroll returns to Newcastle, lowering his salary expectations. He is still a household name in the UK.
Brief Reading Spell
Carroll has short stint with Reading, his career winding down. A lack of consistent high-level play begins to affect his image.
Dagenham & Redbridge Player
Carroll plays for Dagenham & Redbridge. His net worth decreases as his career comes to an end and investments fluctuate.
Last updated: February 21, 2026